
You must post 2 times before next Monday, April 11th. Your first post should be submitted by Thursday, April 7th. It is to be in response to one of the prompts below. The second time you post, it must be in response to or in reaction to the post of another student.
1. One Hundred Years of Solitude is seeped in symbolism, allegory, hyperbole and parable. (These literary terms are defined below.) Why do you think Gabriel Garcia Marquez chooses to write his narrative in this way? Choose an aspect of the novel that makes use of one of the aforementioned literary devices then attempt to give meaning to it.
Symbolism: a word or phrase referring to a concrete object, scene, or action which also has some further significance associated with it
Allegory: a story or visual image with a second distinct meaning partially hidden behind its literal or visible meaning. The principal technique of allegory is personification. In written narrative, allegory involves a continuous parallel between two or more levels of meaning in the story. An allegory may be conceived as a metaphor that is extended into a structured system.
Hyperbole: Exaggeration for the sake of emphasis
Parable: A brief tale intended to be understood as an allegory illustrating some moral or lesson.
2. Choose a particular character to evaluate. Determine whether the character traits you have noted are ultimately positive or negative, or both. Explain your reasoning. For example Jose Arcadio Buendia: He is inventive and spends many hours alone on his alchemy experiments trying to discover already known science. This is ultimately negative, because he isolates himself from his family and eventually goes mad.
3. Identify elements of the story that you find particularly confusing, interesting, or worthy of discussion. Pose your own questions. Include portions of the text that you feel contribute to your questions/your point. Cite page numbers.
Amaranta: I think she was hardened by love. When we first meet her she seemed normal, but then Rebeca goes with Crespi and she starts to build up walls. She starts to threaten Rebeca. Even when Crespi does fall in love with her instead of marrying him she refuses to be with him. Crespi ends up killing himself because of this. Then because Amaranta feels so guilty she burns herself. This is ultimately negative because she turns away from love, and her family and ends up being masochistic.
ReplyDeletein response to #3, i find in this story all of the names to be particularly confusing. some names are repeated and others are similar like arcadio and auriliano. when thinking back through the story i have difficulties with remembering what happened to who. also this book has flash backs which confuses me as to when it is a flashback to when it is the present time in the book
ReplyDeleteRebeca: I believe that she is messed up. Ever since she became a part of this story she was a very weird person. When she first showed up with a bag of bones to her eating the earth and white wash off the walls. And now after the death of her husband she becomes a hermit. The traits that i mentioned above are ultimately negative actions. Because she never goes outside and is never seen.
ReplyDeleteJose Arcadio: Though he was with the gypsies while most of the characters were developing, I think Jose Arcadio can tell us a lot about the story. Part of the story is the changing characters and more importantly the views of other characters about that character. I think that Jose Arcadio gives off a bad vibe because he left with the gypsies. Then everyone, including his own nother Ursula, is made even more angry when he runs off with Rebeca. It seems like the author is attempting to make us dislike Jose Arcadio. Right when it seems like he can't get any worse, he does a knoble thing like saving Colonel Aureliano Buendia. I think even Ursula would change her opinion about Jose Arcadio after that action. Overall, I think that the way Jose Arcadio acted at the begining and the way the author portrays his action has a negative affect because we aren't able to see how great he could truely be.
ReplyDeleteIn response to XSecretAssassinX: i agree with how it seems that all the names are the same. When a new baby is born it is named either after its father or mother or grandmother or grandfather and when everyone is naming their kids the same name that they have everything gets pretty confusing.
ReplyDeleteIn response to Jared, I think that something really is wrong with Rebeca. The fact that her husband is mysteriously killed and the only one who is around is Rebeca raises a few questions, but I don't think she did it. I think she is just heart broken and doesn't want to see any one, though not leaving does stir some questions, Jared.
ReplyDeleteAmaranta: Is a very odd, like everyone else in the book. I find Amaranta to be very obsessed with things, she throws away all her wants and becomes consumed with thoughts of revenge and/or hatred. Just like when she wanted to marry Pietro, but Pietro was going to be married to Rebecca. Amaranta became obseesed with preventing the wedding from occuring. When Rebecca and Pietro go there seprate ways; Amaranta gets the man she always wanted, Pietro, but when Pietro asked her to marry him she said NO. but Why? She was so obsessed with Revenge she turned down what she truly wanted. She is so insane that she cant accept what she can get and wants because of her thirst for revenge.
ReplyDeleteIn the past reading when Amaranta puts her hand in hot coals is alittle much even if she felt guilty for killing Pietro. She is crazy and lost her mind and she should be tied to the tree like Jab.
ReplyDeleteUrsula: she is basically just a huge B.A. and even though she isn't technically the leader of the town she kind of runs things when they really get out of control. i don't thing she is crazy either like the rest of the characters. What and original gangster.
ReplyDeleteRebeca:I feel that she is rather desperate. She was supposed to marry Pietro and grew tired of waiting, and went behind his back to have an affair with Jose Arcadio. She liked how masculine he was and let no time go to waste, getting right down to business. Also, the fact that she ended up marrying him is a bit odd, because even though they aren't blood related they are still family. I would say this is ultimately negative because it causes tension within the family with Ursula kicking them out of the house and now that Jose Arcadio has died, Rebeca is left with no one and is miserable.
ReplyDeleteUrsala because she is able to take control and get the town back on its feet. Shes a person that if she sees a problem she wants to fix it for the better of the town. She is a strong spirited person and wont stop for anything. She looks out for the better good of the people. Ursala lays down the law.
ReplyDeleteIn response to Emily, I agree completely going and marrying someone u grew up with in the same house and playin another guy like a little tease is unruly. She needs to be put in her place. And of corse Ursala was the perfect one to do it.
ReplyDeleteI think that Ursula is the one who really is charge of the town regardless of who carries the title. She is not afraid to beat someone down, or let everyone know how she feels. She is the one who makes sure that things are running smoothly. If things aren't going how she wants them to, she will make sure that she speaks up about it
ReplyDeleteAmaranta: She seems to do whatever she can to get things to happen her own way no matter what it does to anyone else. First she sabotages Pietros and Rebeccas marriage which leads to that one girl dying. Then she turns down Pietro out of spite when he comes to her which ends in him killing himself. then she turns down another suitor because she feels bad for herself.
ReplyDeleteIn response to Ashley, I agree i think Ursula is the one who is in charge of the town. She is like the mother hen. And she challenges men and their weapons even though she posses none. She knows how macondo should be run and she makes sure that everyone follows by that guideline. No matter if there is an army or a dictator of Macondo, Ursula is the one in charge.
ReplyDeleteUrsula is the mother of all. She is married to JAB. She is a kind person, when JAB is tied to the tree, she goes to visit him and bring him news. She takes in Rebeca and raises her as her own. She tries to keep the Buendia family together. This job can be tough at time because she had to kick out jose arcadio and rebeca from her house for sleeping with each other. She is a very strong women and that is a positive and negative. it is negative because her family may take her as mean and harsh, but love is tough sometimes.
ReplyDeleteto reponse to numer 3, i think all the names in the boook are confusing half the time i dont know who their talking about in the book, when all have the same name.
ReplyDeleteto response to meredith, i do agree with her that ursula is the ruler of the town because she scared everyone that confonts her
ReplyDeleteIn response to Ashley, I also agree with what Meredith is saying. Although Macondo has no guidelines i feel that Ursula has kind of set some of her own by taking control. Going back to Ashley's comment about Ursula speaking up when she wants something I completely agree with, like when she kicked Rebeca and Jose Arcadio out of the house and they are family.
ReplyDeleteIn response to Emily i would agree that Rebecca is desperate. She is so self centered. She is only concerned with herself, s he doesn't care who she hurts. she needs to be more concerned with the feelings of others.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Ashley, she needs to care about someone else besides herself and maybe people will respect her and treat her better as well.
ReplyDeletei agree with emily. Rebeca is quite desperate. she married a man that was basically her brother, even though they were not blood related. It is also strange that she left a man that loved her and she loved in order to marry him. that is just weird. it is a negative thing because she ends up getting kicked out of the family and she is accused of killing Jose.
ReplyDeletein response to newt. i would definitely agree that rebecca is a weird person although i think has become a bit more sane as the story continues, also we haven't heard much of her lately so i am beginning to wonder if she will see her way back into the story a little more.
ReplyDelete3. I think the reusing the names is really confusing because at points the people are still alive and they are sometimes in the same scene it gets really confusing. I'm sure Marques can still get his point across without using the same names. I can understand why he uses the same names though because people that have the same names have similar traits.
ReplyDeleteIn response to Sam the fact that Amaranta burned her hand because she feels guilty for the death of Pietro doesn't mean that she should be tied to the tree. Everyone is a little different in their life choices, but that doesn't mean that people that act differently than other people doesn't mean that they should be quarantined or put somewhere different than other people.